Philip Spiess
Herewith ALONG THE GREAT MIAMI II: THE HARRISONS OF NORTH BEND: The rightful heirs to the lands of the Great Miami River and its fertile flood plains were, of course, the Native Americans, most notably, in this part of the country, the Miami “Indians” [see Part I]. But following the American Revolution, as the former colonists of Great Britain began to expand and push westward, ever seeking new territory to farm and develop, the traditional peoples who had settled this land centuries before were pushed out, sometimes peacefully with what turned out to be specious treaties, but more often with the force and violence of battle and war, weapons used and blood spilled. The Ohio Country had long been a part of the British colony of Virginia, land graciously allotted to it by King George II in 1749 and even surveyed for the royal governor by the young Virginian colonist George Washington. At the close of the Revolutionary War, however, as the new government of the United States sorted out war debts and land claims, the southern part of the Ohio Country was taken from Virginia and sold to speculators from New Jersey. Central to this story in the Great Miami Valley was the clan of the Symmes family of New Jersey and its future relatives, the Harrison family of Virginia.
Something of John Cleves Symmes: John Cleves Symmes of New Jersey (1742-1814) was the principal land purchaser and developer of the land between the Great Miami and Little Miami Rivers on the Ohio River following the Revolutionary War, a land development which came to be known as the “Symmes Purchase” and which was the site of the future city of Cincinnati and Hamilton County. Though a pioneer of the Old Northwest Territory, Symmes was born in Riverhead, New York, trained as a lawyer, and, being a supporter of the American Revolution, became chairman of the Sussex County, New Jersey, Committee of Safety in 1774. He served as a Colonel in the Continental Army and was elected to what is now the New Jersey Senate, as well as serving on the New Jersey Supreme Court (1777-1778). He represented New Jersey in the Continental Congress (1785-1786), but then, in 1788, he purchased 311,682 acres from the Congress and moved west to the Ohio country in the Old Northwest Territory. (For the rest of his life this purchase created considerable controversy, caused in part by other investors as partners and by disputes about the actual boundaries of the purchase and the validity of titles.)
Symmes and his family (his first wife had died in 1776, but not before producing three daughters, one of whom, Anna Tuthill Symmes, married Lt. William Henry Harrison [see below; it was a clandestine marriage – some say elopement]) settled on the western edge of the Symmes Purchase near the mouth of the Great Miami River, at what eventually became the village of North Bend, Ohio [see below]. Established in his new home, Symmes pursued an active career as a land developer and seller; he also served as a judge of the Territorial Court from 1788 until Ohio became a state in 1803. In 1794, Symmes married a second time, this time to the daughter of Governor William Livingston (the first United States governor of New Jersey), Susannah Livingston (who was also John Jay’s sister-in-law). Symmes died in 1814 in Cincinnati and is buried in North Bend’s Congress Green Cemetery [see below].
The Log Cabin and Hard Cider Campaign of 1840: The Presidential campaign of 1840, pitting Whig candidate William Henry Harrison against Democrat Martin Van Buren, former Vice President under President Andrew Jackson, has come down in history as the “Log Cabin and Hard Cider Campaign.” It came about in this way: a Democratic newspaper, writing a derisive editorial about the Whig candidate, said, “Give him a barrel of hard cider and settle a pension of two thousand a year on him, and my word for it he will sit . . . by the side of a ‘sea coal’ fire, and study moral philosophy.” The Whigs, picking up on this political blunder, turned it around and presented their candidate as a simple frontier Indian fighter, living in a log cabin (the original structure at North Bend, Ohio, a log cabin, had long since been enclosed in the middle of a sturdy Federal style wooden mansion) and drinking hard cider, a beverage easily produced from John Chapman’s (“Johnny Appleseed’s”) Midwestern apples – this in contrast to Van Buren, who was living in a brick mansion at Kinderhook, New York (now a National Historic Site), giving aristocratic parties and drinking champagne. [I do not have a recipe for Harrison’s particular style of hard cider, but I do have the recipe for “General Harrison’s Egg Nogg: 1 egg; 1 ½ teaspoonful of sugar; 2 or 3 small lumps of ice. Fill the tumbler with [hard] cider, and shake well. This is a splendid drink, and is very popular on the Mississippi River. It was General Harrison’s favorite beverage.” So says Jerry Thomas, compiler of the first alcoholic drink recipe book ever published (1862, a copy of which I have). Well, it did have hard cider in it!]
Despite the Whiggish fluff, William Henry Harrison was born to the planter aristocracy of Virginia at Berkeley Plantation, a fine Georgian house on the James River (which can be visited when the pan-demic is not on), in 1773. His father, Benjamin Harrison V, was a signer of the Declaration of Independence. William Henry himself studied classics and history in college, then began the study of medicine. But in 1791 he became an ensign in the 1st Infantry of the Regular Army and headed to the Old Northwest Territory. Serving as aide-de-camp to General “Mad” Anthony Wayne at the Battle of Fallen Timbers (which ended conflicts with the Indians in western Ohio for a time, thus opening much of the Ohio Country to white settlement [see Part I]), in 1798 Harrison became Secretary of the Old Northwest Territory and its first delegate to Congress, pushing legislation that divided the Territory into the Northwest and Indian Territories. In 1801 he became Governor of the Indiana Territory (capital at Vincennes), serving twelve years. As governor, his task was to obtain title to Indian lands so settlers could settle the “wilderness”; when the Indians retaliated, Harrison was responsible for defending the white settlements. But by 1809 the mighty Native American chieftain Tecumseh and his religiously-oriented brother The Prophet began to develop an Indian confederation to push back against the white settlements. In 1811 Harrison was allowed to attack the confederacy; he therefore led about 1,000 men toward The Prophet’s town, establishing a camp on the Tippecanoe River. However, the Indians attacked first, though after heavy fighting Harrison’s troops repulsed them, thus disrupting Tecumseh’s confederacy and leading to Harrison’s fame. And so in the War of 1812, Harrison was made brigadier general and given command of the Army in the Northwest territories. At the Battle of the Thames (north of Lake Erie) in 1813, he defeated the combined British and Indian forces and killed Tecumseh.
Thus the Whigs, looking for a national hero to run for President on their ticket, nominated Harrison for President in 1840. It was what we might call the first “modern” Presidential campaign – the first with campaign “buttons” (well, they were coins at that time, except for one which was a one-inch cube of copper in the form of a log cabin, attached to a watch fob, of which I have one), lapel ribbons imprinted with Harrison’s portrait, and sheet music, such as “The Tippecanoe or Log Cabin Quick Step, composed and respectfully dedicated to Gen. William Henry Harrison (Hero of Tippecanoe and Farmer of North Bend)” [I have some of each in my political campaign collection]. Although Harrison won a majority of the popular vote by less than 150,000, he swept the Electoral College 234 to 60. But his victory was to be short-lived – literally.
“Old Tippecanoe”: President for Life (i.e., a Month): In Harrison’s day, the inauguration of presidents at Washington took place in March; this was due to the effects of winter on poor roads, most of which were simply dirt tracks (there were very few Macadamized, or graded gravel, roads; the National Road, still being built into the Midwest at this time, was the exception), which by February had turned to frozen mud or worse. Thus inaugurations were held after the expected Spring thaw, a circumstance particularly useful for newly-elected Presidents traveling from the Old South or the Midwest, Harrison being the first of these latter. He arrived in Washington in February, 1841, and turned his Inaugural Address over to fellow Whig Daniel Webster to edit. The address, the longest in history – 1 hour and 45 minutes (close, perhaps, to Bill Clinton’s) – was in ornate prose, full of classical allusions, and Webster commented that he had “killed seventeen Roman proconsuls as dead as smelts. . . .” The address, nationalistic in outlook, stated that Harrison would be obedient to the will of the people, as they expressed it through the U. S. Congress.
But alas! Harrison, the oldest President to serve up to that time (he was 68), gave his long speech out of doors in the chill of a March rain, and contracted a cold which turned into pneumonia. He died on April 4, having been President for thirty-three days. He was the first President to die in office. His wife, Anna Symmes Harrison, had been too ill to travel with him, it being a long and difficult trip by steamboat, railroad, and carriage – this was still at that time a frontier journey, and she was 65. She had wished that he had been left in retirement, rather than allowing his friends to run him for office. So she stayed at the wooden mansion in North Bend, Ohio, living there after his death until it burned down in 1858, after which she lived with her last surviving child, John Scott Harrison [see below]. The equestrian statue of William Henry Harrison, at the time of his death first citizen of Hamilton County and therefore a memorial to him, located at the head of Piatt Park in Cincinnati just across from the main Public Library on Vine Street, was sculpted by two notable Cincinnati sculptors, Louis Rebisso and Clement Barnhorn; it was installed in 1896 (and is about to be removed under political correctness, if certain City Councilmen have their way).
North Bend, Ohio: North Bend, Ohio, located near the mouth of the Great Miami River where it debouches into the mighty Ohio, is situated fifteen miles west of downtown Cincinnati and six miles east of the Ohio/Indiana border. Named for the most northerly bend of the Ohio River between the Muskingum and Mississippi Rivers, it was settled by John Cleves Symmes [see above] in 1789, the two previous “Symmes Purchase” settlements, Columbia on the Little Miami River, and Losantiville (later Cincinnati) on the Mill Creek, being settled earlier and upstream. It was incorporated as a village in 1845. Besides being the long-time home of the 9th President of the United States, William Henry Harrison (who is buried here; see below), and the birthplace of his grandson, the 23rd President of the United States, Benjamin Harrison, it was also the birthplace of Eliza Hendricks, wife of Thomas A. Hendricks, Vice President under President Grover Cleveland in his first term, as well as the site of an early hold-up of a railway train.
John Scott Harrison: The Missing Corpse: And now we come to a curious history: not the life, but the “after-life,” of a man distinguished mainly as being “the grandson of a signer of the Declaration of Independence,” “the son of a President” and “the father of a President” – in other words, John Scott Harrison (1804-1878). Although he had a fairly illustrious career in his time – member of the U. S. House of Representatives from Ohio (1853-1857) – he retired from public life to his estate, “Point Farm,” in North Bend, Ohio, where he died in his sleep on May 25, 1878. Prior to his own death in 1841, his father, William Henry Harrison, had selected a knoll, Mount Nebo, on his property at North Bend, Ohio, overlooking the Ohio River, as the site for his and the family’s tomb. Accordingly, it was built – a barrel-arched brick structure with sod covering the structure’s roof (much like Washington’s “Old Tomb” at Mount Vernon). Shortly after the late president’s interment, the family installed an iron door on the tomb, and in 1879 the structure’s deteriorating brick was covered with stucco. and a flat flagstone roof replaced the sod above the barrel arch. It was here that the recently deceased John Scott Harrison was laid to rest by family and friends on May 29, 1878.
Let us now digress for a moment and consider the American “way of death” (and the English one as well) at this time in history. The end of the 18th century and the course of the 19th century saw the rise of, and great progress in, the practice of medicine, based, ever so gradually, on real scientific inquiry. But this inquiry had its problems and pitfalls: if you wished to study – to actually cut into – the human body as a medical student, where did you get one? (A study of the plates in Andreas Vesalius’s great work on anatomy only went so far.) Answer: you, or your medical school, had to have one given to you (unlikely), you had to dig one up (but it had to be rather fresh), or you had to steal one (voila!). Enter the “professional” “Resurrection Men,” the corpse thieves of the 19th century. [You remember Jerry Cruncher, the body-snatcher of Dickens’ A Tale of Two Cities, don’t you? Or read Robert Louis Stevenson’s 1881 “The Body Snatcher,” or look up “Burke and Hare” on the Internet. This is why my great-grandmother told me that they used to release packs of wild dogs in Spring Grove Cemetery in Cincinnati after closing for the day – they’d fire a cannon as warning, then the dogs would roam the premises attacking any invaders.]
But to return to John Scott Harrison. During his funeral at Congress Green Cemetery in North Bend, folks attending the event noticed that the grave of Augustus Devin, who had died eleven days earlier of tuberculosis, had been seriously disturbed, and young Mr. Devin was no longer within. Horrified and concerned, John Scott’s three sons, Benjamin (the future President), John, and Carter, saw to it that their father’s grave in the tomb described above was reinforced with three large stone slabs over the casket and covered with cement. After the cement had dried, the tomb was filled up, the iron door locked, and a watchman paid $30 to guard the tomb for thirty nights.
So far so good. But wait! There’s more! The very next day, son John Harrison and his cousin, George Easton, got a search warrant, and, backed up by three Cincinnati policemen, began looking for Augustus Devin at Cincinnati’s largest and most prominent medical school, the Medical College of Ohio. They had reason to investigate: that morning’s Cincinnati Enquirer had reported that at 3:00 a.m. a buggy had driven into the alley between Vine and Race Streets next to the Medical College, and from it “something white was taken out and disappeared” before the buggy “left rapidly. . . . The general impression was that a ‘stiff’ was being smuggled into the Ohio Medical College.”
John Harrison, his cousin, and the police were met by the medical school’s janitor, J. Q. Marshall, who showed them over the building. In the cellar they found a chute connecting to a door in the alley; the chute became a vertical shaft running to the top of the building. On other floors they found boxes of various body parts and the body of a 6-month-old baby, as well as students in the process of dissecting dead bodies. Finally they were taken to the top floor, where they found a windlass and a rope running into a square hole in the floor, which turned out to be the top of the shaft they had seen in the cellar, the windlass being used to lift cadavers to the upper stories of the Medical College. Detective Snelbaker of the Cincinnati Police force decided to turn this windlass – and up came the body of a naked man on a hook. “It’s Father!” cried John – for it was indeed the body of John Scott Harrison, buried less than twenty-four hours before at North Bend under supposedly “secure” circumstances, but whose body had been dumped into the College’s chute at 3:00 a.m.!
Needless, to say, a national scandal occurred: investigation of the tomb at Congress Green Cemetery in North Bend uncovered the fact that the stones that had been placed at the foot of the interred coffin were displaced, the casket had been drilled into, and the lid had been pried back so that the body could be hauled out by the feet. It was clear that the grave robbers had been present at the funeral and had taken note of all of the security arrangements. The paid watchman had no explanation [!].
The Medical College of Ohio was raked over the coals in the local press, but the college faculty was boldly unrepentant. They thought, they said, that they were receiving the body of another pauper [!], but that was the cost of doing competent doctor training! Dr. Robert Bartholow, Dean of the College (who four years before had killed a patient by inserting electrodes deep into her brain for an experiment), stated in the Cincinnati Times that he took no responsibility for an “anonymous resurrectionist” taking “this means to replenish his exchequer.” Son Benjamin Harrison responded (in part): “Have you so little care of your college that an unseen and unknown man may do all this? Who took him from that [preliminary to dissecting] table and hung him by the neck in the pit?” He thereupon filed a civil suit and the city filed a criminal suit, but the outcomes of the cases are lost; they were destroyed in the Hamilton County Court House Riots of 1884 [see my reference on an earlier Forum posting]. John Scott Harrison’s body was eventually reinterred in the family tomb at North Bend, Ohio, and one may suspect that it is still there (or not?).
However, further investigation of Cincinnati’s other medical colleges (it had been an important Midwest center for the study of medicine ever since the early days of Dr. Daniel Drake) uncovered a ring of cadaver and body part suppliers that stretched all the way from Cincinnati to Lake Erie and beyond – the body of Augustus Devin was later found, along with the parts of numerous other bodies, in the pickling vats of the University of Michigan. However, because of the national publicity of this case, the states of Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Iowa, and Michigan passed or amended Anatomy Acts that increased the penalties for grave robbing and allowed medical schools to use unclaimed bodies of people who died in the care of the state (paupers, orphans, the insane, and prisoners) for anatomical dissection. (As part of my self-imposed Victorian studies, I visited the anatomy labs of Indiana University in 1971 to see the medical students cutting the cadavers apart and playing “toss” with the brains; it was quite edifying.) Requiescat in pace (in parte).
Harrison, Ohio: The city of Harrison, Ohio, named in honor of William Henry Harrison, was laid out in 1810. It was the home of Ohio’s fifth governor, Othniel Looker (his house still stands; it is on the National Register of Historic Places and is open several days a year). Harrison was incorporated in 1850 and became a city in 1981. The township of Harrison was established in 1850; it was formerly part of Crosby Township. Among its historic sites is the Eighteen Mile House, built about eighteen miles from Cincinnati during the earliest years of the 19th century near a toll gate on the toll road between Cincinnati and Brookville, Indiana. It has served as a tavern, an inn, and a post office; it was later expanded on the north side. Local legend says that Lincoln stayed there once [?]; Morgan’s Raiders [Confederate] attacked the property during the Civil War. The site was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1975.
Harrison was also one of the few stops in Ohio on the Whitewater Canal, most of which is in Indiana. The canal, built between 1836 and 1847, stretched for 76 miles (I’ve canoed and hiked portions of it); one of its unique features is near Metamora, Indiana, where a covered-bridge sluice carries the canal over the Whitewater River. It was gradually replaced by the railroad, which came to Harrison in 1864. And in 1932 a dog racing track in West Harrison (just over the border in Indiana) opened, despite the fact that pari-mutuel betting was illegal in Indiana (officials looked the other way, as during the Great Depression it brought revenue into the area). It must have been colorful: monkeys in silk jackets were used as jockeys for the dogs, but the whole enterprise closed in 1940, due to pressure from the horse-racing industry. Harrison, Ohio, is also home to the American Watchmakers-Clockmakers Institute, a trade association dedicated to the advancement of the modern watch industry. The Institute’s ELM Charitable Trust operates The Orville R. Hagans History of Time Museum and The Henry B. Fried Resource Library, both of which are located at AWCI headquarters in Harrison. (You may visit them when the pandemic is over if you have time on your hands.)
Congress Green Cemetery and the Harrison Memorial Today: In the early 1800s, on land owned by William Henry Harrison’s family, the residents of North Bend, Ohio, established what was initially called the “Pasture Graveyard.” Harrison’s father-in-law, John Cleves Symmes, was buried there. Later Symmes and Harrison family members, as well as other local citizens, were buried there, in what eventually came to be known as Congress Green Cemetery. In 1871 Harrison family members sold their estate, with the exception of the six acres of Congress Green Cemetery, John Scott Harrison offering the site to the state of Ohio if it would be preserved. Burials there were closed in 1884.
I have mentioned above the early structure of the Harrison tomb and some subsequent renovations. In the early 1880s (possibly at the time burials in the cemetery closed), local residents formed a memorial association, helping the Harrison family care for the site; later they added new stonework to enlarge the structure. In 1919, the William Henry Harrison Memorial Commission formed and convinced the State of Ohio to take over ownership of the site. That same year (1919), the state legislature repaired the structure and added the two eagle-topped pillars and the balustrade to the cemetery’s entrance. And then, in 1924, recognizing that a presidential tomb site required some dignity, the state legislature authorized the construction of the 60-foot brick tower, clad in Bedford limestone, above the tomb as an appropriate memorial; it is visible to boats passing on the Ohio River, particularly when lit up at night. In 1932 the state transferred the tomb’s care and preservation to the Ohio Historical Society (now the Ohio History Connection) as a State Historic Memorial, which maintains the site along with the Harrison-Symmes Memorial Foundation, which is located, with its museum, in Cleves, Ohio (about one mile from the tomb).
[Note: The Congress Green Cemetery now is also the site of a state environmental project to preserve an endangered species, the Running Buffalo Clover (Trifolium stoloniferum), a Midwest prairie plant.]
|