Philip Spiess
As promised:
DOUBLE, DOUBLE TOILET TROUBLE:
A Two-Seater of Comedy and Tragedy
Part II: The Pleasant Ridge Privy Disaster
Prologue: In Tenebris: Without warning, the floor on which the young girls were standing gave way. Down they fell, into the murky depths, into the foul odors, into the Stygian waters – and darkness and death surrounded them.
Causa Mali: It was a rather modest and fairly crude schoolyard privy or outhouse, and perhaps that was the reason for its downfall: nobody paid it much attention. As it was the girls’ privy, it was on the girls’ side (east side) of the Pleasant Ridge Public School playground. Constructed in 1893, it was a whitewashed 10-foot-square frame building, built over a 12-foot-deep stone privy vault, which had that day about four feet of foul water and human waste in the pit. Thus it was giving off rather noxious fumes, although the outhouse was ventilated, and somewhat illuminated, by a round window in each of the two gable ends. (It is surprising that the outhouse had a privy pit, because Pleasant Ridge had a sewer system, but the school privies were not connected to the system.) Because it saw a lot of use, the eleven-year-old privy had been repaired several times.
In fact, just in the past year (1903) a carpenter had installed new seats in the privy (there were four on each of the three walls, the fourth wall containing the narrow entrance), new flooring, and new siding. Assuming that the building was sound, the carpenter had laid the new floor over the old one, never checking to see if the old floor joists were in good condition. Unfortunately, they weren’t; they were sodden with years of moisture, and the ends of the boards were grooved where they attached to the sides of the vault. Further, Henry Swift, who had been the Pleasant Ridge School janitor from 1884 to 1903, said that in April of 1903 he had noticed that some stones had fallen out of the foundation wall where the west side of the privy vault was on a slope, making a hole about two feet in diameter. Although the building committee of the school board was told about it, the problem still had not been fixed over a half year later. When Swift left to work at the Kennedy Heights School, he said he was fearful that the building would collapse.
His warnings proved to be all too accurate. On the morning of September 23, 1904, the sky looked like rain, but the principal, Thomas L. Simmerman, sent the elementary school kids out for mid-morning recess at about 10:15. Then the skies opened with a vengeance. The boys and most of the girls ran back inside the school building, but about thirty-one girls tried to crowd into the girls’ privy instead. As they were pushing and shoving each other to get in out of the rain, and some of the girls were dancing and jumping, the entire floor gave way and fell nearly eight feet straight down, crashing to the bottom of the vault and disintegrating in foul water four feet deep. It carried with it a load of stunned and frightened girls.
One girl, Elsie Ferguson, said she felt the floor going and jumped to clutch the side of the door, which left her hanging there; she pulled herself up and got out. Five other girls escaped the same way. Another, Lorena Ferguson, was just entering the privy and was standing on the door sill when the floor dropped away in front of her; her friend, Clara Steinkamp, was behind her and grabbed the back of her dress to keep her from falling. A few girls had managed to climb up on the new toilet seats to make room for others; they were able to hop from one seat to another to get to the doorway and thus escape to safety. But a number of the girls, like Hazel Senour, felt themselves sinking and smothering. Hazel reported later that she caught hold of the stones on the side and held herself up so she could breathe. She further stated, “I felt the soft, struggling bodies of lots of girls around me and underneath me somewhere. They touched me. I could see some heads sometimes and then feet.” Edna Gerke confirmed this: “Everything became dark. Everybody was clutching at her neighbor while there was a terrible outcry. I think every girl was crying at the top of her voice. We were all tangled up with each other and struggled to get free. I was pushed about and some attempted to climb up on my shoulders. I made a grab for a stone I could see projecting above my head, and for a moment held on, but there were so many tugging at me that the weight tore my hold loose and I went down. Even then the struggle continued under the water. With desperation I freed myself and looking up saw daylight which I never expect to behold again.”
The Cincinnati Enquirer wrote that in the struggle “the weaker ones were crushed down by the stronger and forced under the mass of filth to their death.” On investigating the privy later, the Hamilton County Coroner, Walter B. Weaver, summed it up: “Rotten, rotten, rotten. Everything was rotten. Those joists would not hold anything.”
De Profundis: In 1904 the Pleasant Ridge Public School had an enrollment of 297 children; about fifty of those came from the village of Rossmoyne, whose school had been condemned by the state, and the village had failed to pass a school bond to provide a new one. The upper floor of the Pleasant Ridge School included a high school classroom for the four high school boys studying there. Their teacher was Miss Una Venable, daughter of William Henry Venable, chairman (from 1896) of the English department at Walnut Hills High School [see Post #6060 (9-5-2022)].
When the privy floor collapsed, two little girls ran into the school and hysterically told Principal Simmerman what had occurred. He did not immediately understand from their hysterical utterances what had happened, but he went to investigate. Another girl informed Miss Venable, and she and the four high school boys ran to the outhouse, meeting Principal Simmerman there. The sight of the girls, some as young as 7 or 8, others young teenagers, scrambling to climb the walls or struggling to keep their heads above the human waste – all screaming “Save me!” – caused the principal to almost faint.
Across the street at the Presbyterian Church manse were Pastor Ira D. Lambert, town barber Gilright, two young men, William Schultz and John Corell, and a few others. They heard the screams of the girls running from the outhouse to the school and went to investigate. Seeing the mass of bodies writhing in the filthy pit, they called for rope and some ladders, and the high school boys rushed back to the school to find them. But the school’s step ladders were too short to be of use, and the ropes were clotheslines that were as rotten as the privy floor had been.
Meanwhile, Principal Simmerman had leaned as far as he could over the privy vault’s edge, but he could not reach the girls. So the men from the manse held his legs and lowered him further and he managed to rescue three girls. When the ropes were lowered, girls grabbed them, but they broke and the girls fell back. Then James Smith, a 16-year-old boy, climbed into the school’s belfry and got the bell rope; two more girls were saved this way. Finally a longer ladder was found and, although it could not reach all the way from the vault’s bottom to its ledge, it enabled Simmerman and some of the other men to descend and lift the girls out, passing them from hand to hand, bucket brigade-style. “As fast as Mr. Simmerman handed up the children, I took them and passed them along to others, who carried them to the schoolroom,” Miss Venable said. Most of the girls were unrecognizable; covered with muck and with their eyes clenched shut, they sobbed and gasped for breath.
Later, Hazel Senour reported, “The struggle down there was terrible. As long as I could get out of the water to take a breath of air, I felt sure of being saved, but when I fell back into the hole, I thought it was all over. The girls about me were grabbing onto me. Everyone grabbed at each other, and when we did get a hold on the wall, it was only for a second. I caught hold several times, but when I was pulled at by the others my hand slipped. There were only a few taken out, when I felt something under my feet. It must have been some little girl that had drowned. All the time I prayed. I said my prayers over and over. I could not see after a while, and, as I was praying to the Lord to save me, I found the rake in my hands. When I came into the light, I saw Principal Simmerman. I crawled up and was lifted out.”
14-year-old Edna Gerke, who had previously grabbed at a jutting stone but had slipped away from it, saw it again and had another try, “this time with two hands. Far above me, it seemed, somebody was coming down a ladder and called to me. Suddenly someone took hold of me. I looked back over my shoulder and saw the agonized faces of my friends, then lost consciousness and knew no more until I woke up in the schoolroom surrounded by the bodies of my friends.” Her arms were severely bruised and deeply scratched by the clawing attempts of her classmates to climb out over her. Many of the girls fainted after emerging from the vault, fueling concern that they had succumbed to the vault’s terrible fumes. Rescuers carried the girls to homes adjacent to the school, where they were revived, cleaned up, and comforted.
Mementi Mori: Meanwhile, fearful parents, hearing the news, began to show up at the school. John Steinkamp, a wagon maker, thankfully found his daughter Clara, who told him, “I’m all right,” but then he suddenly asked her, “Where’s your sister Emma?” “I don’t know,” Clara said; “she was in there.” Principal Simmerman had pulled up the last girl, the nineteenth, and he looked into the vault. All was still, just broken pieces of flooring floating around in the foul water. Exhausted and faint from the fumes, he did not realize that there were still girls down there, under the wreckage.
The two young men with Pastor Lambert, William Schultz and John Corell, each took a rake, climbed down the ladder into the vault, and began to look for still-missing girls. Flora Forste was found, unconscious but still alive, and she was hoisted up. Eventually, William Schultz and others would pull nine more girls from the privy; none of the nine survived. The high school classroom in the school became a temporary morgue. Carmen and Fausta Card, aged 7 and 11, were found tightly clasped in each other’s arms, dead; Fausta’s twin, Rotha, had escaped alive. John Steinkamp’s other daughter, Emma, was one of the last bodies to be removed.
By this time, Hamilton County Coroner Walter B. Weaver had arrived. Frantic confusion reigned: rescuers had taken rescued girls to various neighborhood homes to recover, but no one had kept a roster of who had been pulled from the vault or where they went. The routes between the train stations and the school were jammed with crowds; the village’s telephone system was swamped with calls and proved inadequate to the demand. After the vault was emptied, the coroner ordered firemen to pull out the pieces of broken flooring. One reporter on the scene was able to stick the point of his umbrella clear through a six-by-two timber.
By the time night had fallen, three different funds had been started to pay for the nine funerals and to assist the victims’ families. The wife of Mayor J. J. Marvin prosed that a shaft of pure marble be erected in the schoolyard to represent the “pure, carefree, innocent lives” that had been lost. After the nine funerals had taken place, the mayor’s fund to erect said marble marker had accumulated over $1,000, but Miss Una Venable objected to a marker. She put forward that such a marker would be a constant, unwanted reminder of the disaster and suggested a stained-glass window for the school instead. It was then suggested that the marble shaft be placed in the cemetery across the street from the school, but eventually the funds were used for the funerals and for the families involved. Meanwhile, Dr. Senour, who had attended many of the girls as they were pulled out, thought that a set of four medals ought to be presented to Will Schultz and the other young men who had climbed into the vault to pull out bodies.
Aftermath: David Fisher, the local Ohio Inspector of Factories, Workshops and Public Buildings, said that his office was not required to make inspections of school buildings unless there was a complaint – and there hadn’t been one. The village Board of Education convened that night at the home of its president, the Rev. Fred Hohmann. The five attending members issued the following statement: “The Board has done all that was humanly possible to keep the building in a safe condition, having no intimation in any manner of any danger coming to the Board or any member of the Board or to the superintendent or to any one of the teachers. It has been frequently and so far as possible thoroughly inspected and to our best knowledge no foresight could have prevented this tragedy.” President Hohmann even said that for the past six years he had never missed testing the floors of the outhouses by jumping upon them with his own 200 pounds [!]. Thus the Board dodged responsibility.
State Inspector Fisher, on visiting the scene, said, “My lord, they ought not to have used yellow pine for those joists! . . . Gases and water in the vault would rot pine easily. Red cedar ought to have been used. Iron girders ought to have been used. This building has been unsafe almost from its erection because the girders were insufficiently fastened on the framework.” On the day of the funerals, the town was overrun with sightseers, many murmuring that there should be an investigation. School Board member Lewis Brewer commented that “I have heard many words of condemnation for our board, have even heard persons on the cars say we ought to be hung, but I think that’s passing over now.”
The final upshot was that Coroner Weaver cited suffocation as the cause of the deaths and declared gross negligence on the part of the Board of Education. The citizens of Pleasant Ridge registered their outrage by including none of the School Board members on the fall election ticket, rather electing a “Citizen’s Ticket” of new nominees. No charges were ever filed against anyone nor any indictments ever issued.
So the moral perhaps should be: Don’t scrimp on the seemingly mundane and insignificant – a penny pinched is apt to pinch back. Caveat emptor!
[Note: Part I: "The Great Bathtub Hoax" is at Post #6638 (02-14-2024).]
|