Message Forum


 
go to bottom 
  Post Message
  
    Prior Page
 Page  
Next Page      

11/11/19 06:38 AM #4372    

 

Paul Simons

Happy Veterans Day - a couple of links for vets and for all -




11/11/19 06:41 AM #4373    

 

Paul Simons

And a lighter moment, this one relating to the war our parents endured -




11/12/19 08:23 AM #4374    

 

Judy Holtzer (Knopf)

I think I missed that one..... thanks! Jack Benny was huge!!


11/12/19 08:27 AM #4375    

 

Judy Holtzer (Knopf)

By the way, again a lot of rockets being fired over Israel. Thanks goodness, no deaths....yet. Lots of damage to property. There was even a warning siren in my new home, Modiin, this morning. Schools closed from Tel Aviv to the south of Israel today. Over a million kids home.


11/12/19 08:56 AM #4376    

 

Ira Goldberg

Notice: Paul just hit 73 years. Watch out Willie Nelson. 


11/12/19 05:11 PM #4377    

 

Paul Simons

  Thanks Ira. Yes, it’s this time of year when I do have a birthday. My advice is to never publicly show an exact date because that makes it one big step easier for hackers to break into your Amazon account and wreck your financials from there. Re: Willie - there’s one rather significant difference which is that I have always had to keep my day job and he was able to quit his. He’s a true hero.  

Judy - glad you enjoyed the clip but sorry about the rockets. The thing that got lost is that for about 150 years European Jews scraped together their sheckels and slowly bought and then settled and irrigated land in Israel and built a society, an army, a country. They didn’t just fall out of the sky in 1948. That’s why, when the 7 Arab countries surrounding Israel attacked the minute the UN formally divided the British Mandate into Israel and Jordan the Israeli Army was able to beat them off. But this history is not taught in the classrooms of Gaza. Quite obviously and quite painfully for all.  

It’s very important for a country, a people to know their history, both the good and the bad. We are suffering in this country from a total absence of knowledge, understanding, and compassion for the victims of our past as a place where slavery was legal - which it never should have been. Never, and economic policies be damned. And launching hundreds rockets at random locations where civilians live should also never happen. Never.

 

 


11/13/19 01:40 AM #4378    

 

Philip Spiess

Paul and Judy:

Nor is this international history taught much of anywhere.  Little enough of our own history is taught, and then (usually) only from one point of view.  (Read how American history texts for American public schools are subsidized, written, authorized by state legislatures and/or state departments of education, published, sold, and used, state by state -- and you will be gagging in the aisles.)

And then there's that slavery issue.  Not only did many Christian (mostly Protestant) preachers (yeah, mostly in the South, but not always) in the 19th century preach that the Bible (and therefore presumably God and Christ) espoused slavery (it was in the Bible, you know), but such claimers of the rights of "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" as Thomas Jefferson (who recent history tells us sired children upon a black slave of his, Sally Hemmings) never freed their slaves (at least Washington did, but only upon his death, leaving his widow Martha who knows where?).  An exception to this preaching was the Beecher clan of Cincinnati (originally -- and later -- Connecticut) at the Lane Presbyterian Seminary in Walnut Hills -- all of whom were fierce Abolitionists (I won't go into their history now; you can look it up yourselves), but, as I hope you know, Cincinnati, at the border between North and South, was at the crossroads of the "Underground Railroad," and was its center in the Midwest. 

 


11/13/19 05:41 PM #4379    

 

Bruce Fette

Phil,

When I was younger than today, my granfather told me that the underground railroad included a stop on Cary Avenue in College Hill and the Beecher house in North College Hill. 

Do you have more data on that?

We have also heard much about Hariett Tubman lately on NPR and her participation in the railroad, but little mentioned about Cincinnati's roll.

 

 

 


11/14/19 10:29 AM #4380    

 

Judy Holtzer (Knopf)

Point of Information in case you would like to refute, at least partially, the argument that there was slavery in the Old Testament, so "it was good"..... 

True, there was slavery, but Jews were required to offer their slaves freedom after 7 years. I said "offer", since I rather imagine that some, if not many, might desire to stay with their masters. I still remember feeling rather lost and abandoned when I left my parental home to go to university in Chicago. Anyone else have similar memories?


11/14/19 01:55 PM #4381    

JoAnn Dyson (Dawson)

Chattel slavery practiced in the US was very different from the state of slavery Judy references in her post.  It is hard to understand where the common ground is between the emotional impact of going to college by choice with its potential, and the lack of choice and the risks of enslavement, sometimes ended because an exploiter of human beings makes the decision to "grant' freedom.  "Slavery" with an end date is really indentured servitude.

There are several works that tell us the human toll of chattle slavery.  From the classic work of Frederick Douglass' autobiography to a somewhat new novel (based on considerable research), Homegoing by Yaa Gyasi.  Today, slavery is still practiced by exploiters  of human beings--sexual and other labor exploiters.  The effort to end enslavement is sadly has to continue.


11/14/19 02:59 PM #4382    

 

Steven Levinson

Thanks, JoAnn.  Judy, are you juxtaposing your adolescent feelings of anxiety that accompanied going off to college against the comfort and well-being of a cared for slave? 


11/15/19 12:52 AM #4383    

 

Philip Spiess

Bruce:  I'll have to check into that.  The referenced Lane Seminary was in Walnut Hills; just about all of its buildings are gone now, I believe.  Harriet Beecher Stowe's house was by the campus of the seminary (her husband, Calvin Stowe, was a professor there, and her father, Lyman Beecher, although a Congregational minister, was president of this Presbyterian seminary); it is still there, owned by the Ohio Historical Society.  After many, many years of being closed to the public, I am told that it is now open once again as a museum.

I believe that I have heard of a Beecher house in College Hill; I'll check into that, too.

Harriet Tubman is rightfully recognized as a leader in the "Underground Railroad" movement; she is known as "the Moses of her people."  A new (and very nice, as well as informative) Harriet Tubman Underground Railroad National Museum has recently opened on the Eastern Shore of Maryland, south of Cambridge, Md., on the Bucktown Road by the Blackwater National Wildlife Reserve, and, of course, Tubman's gotten recent publicity as the possible replacement for Andrew Jackson on the $20 bill (yeah, right! -- in the present administration?).

There were four major "Underground Railroad" routes from the South to the North:  (1) the Eastern seaboard route, of which Harriet Tubman is recognized as the principal "conductor"; it went up from Georgia, the Carolinas and the Sea Islands, and Virginia, through Maryland, Pennsylvania, and New York, into Canada; (2) the Ohio/Indiana route, of which Levi Coffin (a white minister) was the principal "conductor" (this is what makes Cincinnati the center of the Midwest UGRR -- and this is why the Cincinnati Suspension Bridge was not completed until after the Civil War! -- Kentucky objected that slaves would use the bridge to cross the Ohio River to freedom), which went up from the eastern Southern Gulf States and Tennessee through Kentucky, crossing the Ohio River into Ohio and Indiana (notably at Ripley, Ohio, where the Rev. John Rankin house is an Ohio State Memorial to the abolitionist who helped many slaves, notably "Eliza," of Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin fame -- see chap. 5 --, who actually crossed on the ice there, escape to freedom in the north); (3) the Mississippi/Tennessee River route (no known "conductor," though the possibly spurious, i.e., 20th-century, song, "Follow the Drinkin' Gourd," was a supposed route marker), which wound its way along the eastern bank of the Mississippi River into southern Illinois, and hence to Chicago; and (4) a little-used route, the Atlantic Ocean along the eastern seaboard, slaves traveling by boat, either to Canada or escaping to Europe and/or Africa.

This past Spring I taught a five-week course for our Adult Education program at my church (I am currently the Elder for Adult Discipleship) on the history of African-American spirituals and their origins in Africa, their relation to slavery, the abolition movement, Emancipation, and how the spirituals were appropriated afterwards.  The highlight was the visit and performance/lecture by Sule Greg Wilson, a professional African-American ethno-musicologist.  (Look him up on the internet; you'll be in for a treat!) 


11/22/19 12:45 AM #4384    

 

Philip Spiess

A surprising addendum to the previous entry:

It turns out that, with all of the current talk about the payment of reparations for slavery due to African-Americans, there was one slave in history who actually was paid reparations for her slavery -- and that was in Cincinnati!  According to an article in the Smithsonian Magazine, and reprinted in the current issue of The Week magazine, in 1878 Henrietta Wood, a "spectacled negro woman, apparently 60 years old," won $2,500 in reparations (although she had sued for $20,000) from Zebulon Ward, a white man who had enslaved Wood twenty-five years before.

The story is incredible -- but all too typical -- of what was happening to black Americans in the period of American history between, say, 1820 and the Civil War.  Henrietta Wood had been born into bondage in northern Kentucky, and had been sold out of her family as a teenager, serving as a slave first in Louisville and later in New Orleans to a Frenchman.  The Frenchman abandoned his wife and returned to France in 1844, and the wife took Wood with her to Ohio (a free state) and, in 1848 in Cincinnati, Wood was granted her freedom, her mistress going to the county courthouse and registering Wood as free; the papers were officially recorded.  She spent the next several years doing domestic work around Cincinnati.

Nevertheless, the Frenchman's daughter and son-in-law viewed Wood as their inheritance (after all, slaves were considered "property").  They lived in Covington, just across the river from Cincinnati in Kentucky (a slave state), and in 1853 they persuaded Zebulon Ward, a deputy sheriff in Covington, to pay them $300 for the right to sell Wood as a slave and take the profit for himself, providing he could abscond with her.  Accordingly, Wood was kidnapped by Zebulon Ward, having been betrayed by her boardinghouse mistress, and she was sold back into slavery, where she remained for the next sixteen years!  (The record of her being freed perished in a courthouse fire in 1849; her kidnappers, had, of course, taken her copy of the papers from her.)

I won't go through the vicissitudes of those sixteen years, but Wood was shortly sold at the Natchez slave market and ended up as a slave at Brandon Hall on the Natchez Trace in Mississippi; Gerard Brandon was one of the largest slaveholders in the South, and Wood was flogged aplenty.  At some point, she gave birth to her son Arthur.  But when Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation in 1863, Brandon, detemined to defy the decree, marched some 300 slaves 400 miles into Texas, just days before the U. S. Army entered Natchez to free the slaves.  Thus Brandon kept Wood enslaved on a Texas plantation until several years after the Civil War had ended; she finally returned to Cincinnati in 1869.

Wood found a Cincinnati lawyer who helped her file a lawsuit against Ward, who had kidnapped and sold her, although she was legally free.  Ward was now a wealthy man (he left an estate worth at least $600,000), living in Lexington, Kentucky; his team of lawyers stalled the case in court for a number of years.  Then another setback -- Wood's lawyer was murdered by a client's husband in an unrelated divorce case.  Finally, on April 17, 1878, twelve white jurors in a federal courtroom in Cincinnati, in the case of Wood v. Ward under Judge Phillip Swing, awarded Henrietta Wood, former slave, $2,500 as compensation for more than sixteen years of unpaid labor.  Meager as this was (compared to her claim), it enabled her son, Arthur, to buy a house in Chicago, start a family, and pay for his own schooling; he was one of the first African-American graduates of Northwestern University's School of Law.  This was the only reparation for slavery ever paid to an African-American for enslaved servitude to date!

[The book, by W. Caleb McDaniel, from which he drew the article on which I based this entry, is Sweet Taste of Liberty:  A True Story of Slavery and Restitution in America (2019).]


11/27/19 03:36 PM #4385    

 

Stephen Collett

Thank you Phil for those important stories. That whole history is so important for us exactly for our location and the borders it puts us on. Swing communities in national elections.


11/30/19 06:21 PM #4386    

 

Ann Shepard (Rueve)

I know I've been absent from this page for a while, I just want to let everyone know how much I have valued this website and enjoy dropping in.  The conversations have been so numerous.  I don't think I will ever be able to go back to read them all.
These days, most of you who are (there are 56) my Facebook friends, know where I spend most of my social media time.  I LOVE the Class of 64!  Hope to see many of you at our 3/4 (.75) reunion June 11-12, 2021.  

 


12/01/19 04:20 AM #4387    

 

Jerry Ochs

Ann,

Your absence had me worried.  It's not nice to scare an old man.


12/01/19 06:36 AM #4388    

 

Paul Simons

First Happy Birthday Ann!! 

And many thanks JoAnn, Judy, Phil for some history we all need in confronting the absolutely surreal reality we are living in these days. I know there’s research showing real, measurable neurological, anatomical differences between those on one side of the divide and those on the other, but the history of this country and how one chooses to act in its context matter as well. 


12/07/19 12:30 AM #4389    

 

Philip Spiess

I read in the current issue of The Week this quotation from Kurt Vonnegut:

"True terror is to wake up one morning and discover that your high school class is running the country."

Any comments?


12/07/19 08:46 AM #4390    

 

Paul Simons

Yes Phil and you know what’s even worse? When you’re in a fender-bender car accident and the cop looks from my vantage point like he’s STILL IN high school. But to his credit he interviewed the witness and wrote the report and found the other guy, the fool that turned left into oncoming traffic - I was the oncoming traffic- to be responsible for the wreck. But about who’s running the country - there was a time not so long ago when a fellow - can’t remember the name - ran it and he got out of high school long after we did, and at the time there were a few problems like GM bankrupt and Ford and Chrysler there too and a colossal Wall Street crash and he righted that ship before it sank. So the younger generation can get the job done. Now if you are talking about today, people our age running the country, well, our school song has this verse “High on the hill thy stately dome we see / Symbol of honor, truth and loyalty”...HUH? Honor, Truth and Loyalty? To what? To who?  That’s hilarious. If it wasn’t flat out Shakespearean tragedy it would be hilarious. 

 

 


12/07/19 12:35 PM #4391    

 

Gail Weintraub (Stern)

Phil, I wish it were.


12/07/19 02:27 PM #4392    

 

Bruce Fette

As correctly stated by Paul, and wished by the majority, yes I think most of us learned the importance of honor and service to country and to others. So thanks to Phil and Paul and Gail, and the many who have served with these principles, including the many from WHHS who have served in many capacities throughout their spheres of influence.

 

 

 


12/07/19 05:28 PM #4393    

 

Paul Simons

Bruce that’s one of the nicest things anyone has ever said to me. Usually they just ask for my autograph and then they say “No, no, your real autograph, George Clooney!” But seriously you’re an inspiration. Your profile  photo says a lot. It’s a photo of one of the main characteristics of human beings - the search for knowledge, new knowledge, the drive to go from what is known to what is not. Speaking of our school, and other schools, my deepest admiration is for those who educate themselves to the point where they can effect an immediate one-on-one repair or improvement of someone else’s life. Doctors, nurses, dentists, criminal defense lawyers are examples. They are more and more needed as another type of person, the one who causes damage to others, is ascendant these days, globally.


12/08/19 12:51 AM #4394    

 

Philip Spiess

First, Gail, no truer words were ever spoken:  we know our class -- and some of whom have been running the city, the state, the country (I'm thinking of Arnold Bortz and Steve Levinson, for example) -- are intrepid and moral stalwarts of governance, whom we trust.

Paul!  Honor:  I hope that we of Walnut Hills maintain honor -- to ourselves, our school, our country, and, certainly, to truth and loyalty; Truth:  lord knows, Paul, and I know you know, that truth is an almost rare commodity in this day and age, and that we must maintain it in the face of all dubious political and media provocations against it; Loyalty:  yes, to school, our school, which we still love for what it has given us, but also to our country, which is now being threatened by attacks on our Constitution, which is the mainstay of our country -- WHHS, symbol of Honor, Truth, and Loyalty, indeed!

 


12/08/19 02:14 AM #4395    

 

Philip Spiess

And this one's for Bruce Fette:

Your inquiry at Post # 4381 wondered about Underground Railroad activities in College Hill.  Here are some points of reference:

College Hill, during the antebellum era, became a major stop on the Underground Railroad [cf., Richard Cooper and Dr. Eric R. Jackson's Cincinnati's Underground Railroad (Images of America) (2014)].

The Samuel and Sally Wilson house:  In 1847, Samuel and Sally Wilson, a very active and important abolitionist team, bought several acres of land and a small cabin from Freeman Cary in College Hill.  All of the members of the Wilson family (parents, daughter, and sons) were involved in the Underground Railroad, their house being used as a safe house for at least four years for escaping slaves who sought freedom in the north.

The Zebulon Strong house:  Located on Hamilton Avenue, this house was the home of Zebulon Strong, an abolitionist who was part of the regional abolitionist movement.  His house was one of two residences he used to harbor African-American fugitives.  Runaway slaves would come up the east ravine near the railway line, and hide in the nearby woods until dark, when they'd continue their journey north.  The Strong children would play in the area and leave food and drink for the fugitives.  Behind the Strong's house was a wooded area rarely used by local citizens.  It was the secret route used by the fugitives.  But after the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850 was passed, and the recapture of runaway slaves became more lucrative, much more caution was exercised on these routes.

Bruce:  There may be other sites in College Hill on the UGRR, but these are those I know for now.


12/08/19 07:04 AM #4396    

 

Paul Simons

I don’t want to take more than my share of the conversation but since this website’s server capacity is apparently not limited I’ll just help myself to a bit more of it and pass the mashed potatoes please. Thanks Phil for the details. We get these broad outlines of major historical events that become far less powerful and meaningful in our memories - until the details, the names and places are put forth, and then the whole thing comes alive. To be honest lately I have wondered what it was like to be a slave, also a slave owner or trader, also an abolitionist. I will never know the first, I hope I have never known and will never know the second, but the third, the abolitionist, I think I might have an idea of that. I guess there were those who began to feel, at the age of Greta Thunberg, how horrific slavery was, and who fought it with every breath, and yet went to their graves with slavery still intact. We are likely to go to ours before the graph of carbon emission, polar ice melt, destruction of species and habitat, and authoritarian corruption and its destruction of human lives reaches its zenith and turns downward. Last regarding nominations of WHHS graduates to be Governor Of The Planet I would say that for choosing to recognize necessity over convention Gail herself is qualified for the job. But if she’s too modest, preferring to work behind the scenes, then of course Kate McKinnon, even though she didn’t attend WHHS.


go to top 
  Post Message
  
    Prior Page
 Page  
Next Page